Shady Rest


AUTHOR: Kestabrook



SPOILERS: Hollywood A.D.

DISTRIBUTION: Written initially for “I Made This

Productions” Virtual Season 8. Distribute only to IMTP at

first; two weeks after it airs, archive if you want it, but let

me know where.

DISCLAIMERS: All XF characters are CC’s and company’s; the

others are mine.

FEEDBACK: I love it–if helpful or positive.

COMMENTS: Author’s notes are at story’s end.

SUMMARY: Mulder and Scully journey to an upstate NY town

to solve a mystery — is a ghost plaguing an old hotel?



11:50 p.m., August 17

Belcan, New York

A cool wind wafted into the room, blowing the drapes

toward the bed. In his T-shirt and boxers, Mel Barker

shivered, then sighed — the only noise except for an

occasional passing vehicle. Belcan, New York, was not a

place where he would stay by choice normally, but he was a

day early on the final leg of a cross-country run, and Mel

had decided to splurge, stopping at the Shady Rest to sleep

in a real bed instead of the sleeping berth of his Crown

Industries tractor-trailer.

The Shady Rest, an old, three-story railroad hotel, had

been purchased by a city couple and remodeled into a bed

and breakfast inn. Built over a hundred and fifty years

before, the structure had housed countless travelers

waiting for next-day trains to take them where planes took

their children’s children today. Two floors now served as a

fine place to sleep or to have breakfast.

Mel sighed once more, tired of the cool breeze. He lazily

rolled his fifty-two year old frame from the mattress and

plodded to the open window. His truck was parked below,

conspicuous in the humble surroundings. Belcan wasn’t much

of a town: gas station, volunteer firemen’s hall, mini-

mart, post office, church, ramshackle houses, and a two-

lane highway. He wouldn’t live here, but he’d tolerate one


Mel’s hands paused on the window casing. He could see

lightning flashes reflected in distant, heavy clouds. The

wind’s velocity was increasing, and the storm would

probably reach Belcan within twenty minutes. He inhaled the

fresh country air, glad to smell something besides his

truck cab’s stagnant mixture of cigar smoke and Big Macs.

But as another cool gust hit him, he closed the window,

locking it from force of habit. He ran his hands over the

stubble on his chin, let out a loud belch, and shuffled to

the door to check that it, too, was locked. When satisfied

that it was, he returned to the mattress, turned off the

lamp on the bedside table, and pulled the crisp, white

sheets and puffy comforter over himself.

As Mel’s eyes closed, his mind re-ran countless miles of

expressways, of trees zipping by like the railroad ties

beneath a speeding train, of country music songs blending

as if they were all the same composition. But these finally

faded. Mel turned toward the window, and his mind floated

into dreams of his wife and kids, of bringing their gifts

to them once he returned home.

But the dream ended quickly. Lightning flashed across the

darkened room, and thunder clashed like a roaring cascade.

Mel’s eyes flew open. Storms didn’t scare him much, but

sleeping through them was difficult. He tried pulling the

covers over his ears. When that didn’t work, he tried the

same with his pillows, but still the thunder’s booms shook

him. Finally, he drew his head from beneath the pillows,

deciding to merely try to rest.

But slowly, a chill, like icy trickles of water, crept up

Mel’s spine. Someone or something was in the room. He could

sense it. He lay still, clutching the covers as if they

would protect him. He listened. But no noise — not even

the sound of breath inhaled or exhaled — could be heard.

Mel shivered, waiting anxiously to glimpse the intruder in

the next zing of lightning.

Mel shook. He tried to tell himself that this couldn’t be.

The window and door were both locked. No one could have

gotten into his room without a key, and surely he would

have heard such an entrance. He tried to breathe deeply.

Wondered if he should turn on the light. If he should say

something. Threaten the intruder.

Lighting. Mel’s eyes closed instinctively at the sudden

flash. A hard rain suddenly pelted the window. Clamorous

thunder rolled across the sky.

Mel forced his eyes open just before darkness returned. In

that second and in the glow from the streetlight, he

suddenly saw a form before him. A somewhat human form in

white. Mel tried to catch his breath, to force words from

his mouth. But there was no time.

The form raised its arms. In another lightning flash, Mel

saw the glint of daggers as they plunged toward him. He

felt horror as they savagely stabbed into his body. He

screamed in terror and agony, but his cries disappeared in

the noise of thunder and rain, and dwindled to weak groans

as the daggers plunged into him repeatedly…until,

finally, Mel Barker took his last breath.



2:48 p.m., August 25

Outside Belcan, NY

“Oh, here it is.” Dana Scully looked more closely at the

map spread across her lap, and then pointed with her right

forefinger. “We’re about a quarter of an inch from it.”

Her partner, Fox Mulder, allowed a brief smile as he

steered the car around a curve. “Quarter of an inch, huh?

What’s that in miles, Scully?”

“Hmmmm…about three. We’re almost there.” She looked out

her window at the vast green landscape dotted with farms

and cornfields. “Wherever ‘there’ is.”

“Western New York state. Rural America. Not every day that

you get to see this.”

“No, Mulder. You’re right about that.”

Her sarcasm was not lost on him. “Fresh air. People know

everyone’s names. More relaxed lifestyles. That’s nothing

to complain about.”

“That’s true,” Scully agreed. “And I’ll bet the night life

is just impossible to beat.”

Mulder laughed. “Who needs theaters and nightclubs when

you can have clean air and stars?”

“And smell cows and listen to the corn growing.”

“Now, Scully, you’ve been injured. What better place to


Her temper flared briefly. “Flesh wounds, Mulder. Not a

big deal. Besides, they’re nothing now.”

He shook his head. “I’ll bet.” There was no use arguing

the point. His partner never pampered herself when injured.

“Anyway, you continue that this-place-is-nowhere attitude,

and the locals won’t like you.”

Favoring him with a roll of her eyes, she replied flatly,

“Gee, I’ll have to change that then.”

“Gotta get these people to trust you, or they won’t let

you see their ghost.”

“Yeah, right. A ghost. Tell me once more, Mulder: why were

you called in on this?”

“Not just me, Scully. You were asked to come, too.”

“Uh-huh. By whom?”

“By Belcan’s postmistress. Clarissa McKinnie. The post

office is just across the street from the Shady Rest,


“Yeah. And she called *us* because…?”

“‘Cause she saw… the movie,” Mulder confessed quietly.

“‘The Lazarus Bowl’?” Scully’s head went back against the

headrest of their rented Oldsmobile Intrigue. Her eyes

closed. “That damn movie,” she breathed. “If it’s the last

thing I do, I will go to Skinner, and I’ll…”

“No you won’t. Because I’m gonna get him first.” Mulder

looked over from the driver’s side. His right hand came off

the wheel, and he covered her left hand, taking her fingers

into his own. “This won’t be too bad, Scully. At least

we’re out of D.C. for a bit. And the scenery isn’t awful.”

She squeezed his hand. “No, not if you like lots and lots

of green grass, trees, and fields.”

“There are worse things.”

“True.” She withdrew her hand from his and began to re-

fold the map. “Okay, back to the case.” She straightened an

edge that refused to bend. “This ghost…?”

“According to Clarissa, the Shady Rest…”

“Isn’t that the name of the old hotel on ‘Green Acres’?”

“‘Petticoat Junction’.”

“Right. Really original then.”

“Maybe so. The Shady Rest of Belcan certainly pre-dates

‘Petticoat Junction’. And besides, Scully, if Betty Jo,

Billie Jo, and Bobbie Jo are there, this could be a great


“They’d be too old for you, wouldn’t they?”

Her partner considered this. “Spoilsport.”

Scully smiled. “Anyway…”

“Anyway, according to Clarissa McKinnie, the Shady Rest

has been around since the mid-1800s, and it is known for

having a ghost. In 1923, a railroad conductor, one Cecil

Miller, was murdered in the hotel. He was supposed to ride

a 2 a.m. train, and when he didn’t, the hotel owner called

at his room and found him dead. The murder was never

solved, and the townspeople claim that Cecil’s ghost has

haunted the hotel ever since. However, now the ghost seems

to be murdering guests. Three of them — the latest, Mel

Barker of Burlington, Vermont, just eight days ago.”

“That’s quite a story,” Scully mused. “I’m shaking in my

high heels as you tell it.”

“It’s all true, Scully, I swear.”

“And you really believe this murderer’s a ghost?”

“We’ll find out.”

The car broke over a hill, and they could see a flashing

red traffic light about a half mile before them. Several

houses seemed grouped around the light, and above them rose

a three-story structure.

“Belcan?” Scully’s voice betrayed her disdain.

“Yep. I told you it was a little town.”

“*Little*? Mulder, I…*this* is a town?”

“I believe they actually call it a hamlet.”

“To-be-or-not-to-be a town? If this place were any

smaller, I’d miss it if I blinked.”

Her partner smiled as he braked for the light. “Then don’t

blink, Scully.”


“Oh! It’s you!” Clarissa McKinnie quickly dropped the pile

of letters she was sorting and came to the post office’s

counter. Her brown eyes roamed over the FBI agents, shortly

dispensing with Scully and lingering on Mulder.

“You’re Clarissa?” Mulder observed that the postmistress

was 5′ 6″, well-endowed, dark-haired, and in her forties,

and she possessed an amazingly beautiful face. And as

Scully’s shoe hit his ankle, he stopped staring and

commented, “It’s hard to tell how someone looks from email.”

McKinnie waved a flirtatious hand at him, silver bracelets

clinking on her arm. “Isn’t it? You’re much better looking

than Garry Shandling.”

Scully cleared her throat. “You two met via email?”

“Clarissa — um, Mrs. McKinnie — called me first, Scully.

We decided to correspond through email because it’s


“Yes, Agent Scully. And email is better. You get to know

people through what they write. I saw ‘The Lazarus Bowl,’

and I knew immediately that you two would like the story of

the Shady Rest. And corresponding with Fox showed me that I

was right.”

“I see.” Scully looked up at her partner, her eyebrow

raised and lips set in a flat line. “Mrs. McKinnie, what

does local law enforcement think of this ghost idea?”

“Who knows? Local law enforcement consists of the county

sheriff in Ridgemont, and the New York State Police who are

forty miles from here in Wellston. There’s a troopers’

satellite station down the road a bit, but they don’t do

anything without the main base’s permission. The troopers

turned the case over to The Bureau of Criminal

Investigation, but they’re in another county, and bigger

cases take priority over ours. They did investigate the

murders but couldn’t find any motive — no robbery, no

signs that anyone in town knew the murdered guests. And

they found no fingerprints, hairs, or fibers. Not even

footprints. Doors and windows were locked from the inside.

And we haven’t heard anything from BCI as to their

conclusions.” Clarissa rubbed her hands together. “The plot

thickens, eh?”

Scully was unimpressed. “That’s easy enough to explain.

The owners must have a master key to each room. Are the

owners under suspicion?”

The postmistress shook her head. “You’d have to ask the

troopers for sure, but I don’t think so. Bruce and Sheila

Morgan are fairly nice people. And they were visiting

friends the nights the murders were committed. So they had

an alibi.”

“How long have the Morgans had the Shady Rest?” Mulder

asked, leaning his elbow on the counter.

“They started it up again last year in October.”

“Started it again?”

Clarissa leaned on the counter, too. “Well, it had been

out of business since the early ’60s. Passenger trains

weren’t that common around here then, and any real

businesses in the area were all either shutting down or

moving to Buffalo or Rochester. So the old hotel wasn’t

making money. Train usage through here was finished by the

’70s; the tracks were even taken out shortly after that.”

“And the hotel?” Scully persisted.

“Continued to rot away, basically. The Morgans are city

folks, and they wanted to start a business in the country.

Two years ago they came out here for our Indian Summer

Festival — that’s in October — saw the Shady Rest, and

decided it was their new project. They renovated and opened

it as a bed and breakfast last October. There’s also a

craft shop on the first floor. Sheila makes things, or

handles consignment for the area’s other craft people.”

“Why hadn’t this *ghost* bothered the town before

January?” Scully wondered. “Where was it throughout the

past four decades?”

“You see, no one went into the hotel in all that time,”

Clarissa explained. “There was no reason to. The place was

falling down; the windows were boarded up. We figure ol’

Cecil was happy in there by himself — and then when the

Morgans came, he went berserk. He obviously didn’t want to

share his living quarters. But why he waited from October

to January to be violent is beyond me.”

“He’d never killed anyone before?” Mulder asked.

“Nope. From the time he was murdered till the last guest

stayed there in the ’60s, Cecil only rattled windows or

moved things around in the rooms. Made some noises —

opened cupboards or closets in the middle of the night. But

never violent.”

Scully nodded and extended her hand. “It was nice to meet

you, Mrs. McKinnie. I think we’ve got all the information

we need for now.”

“Nice to meet you, too, Agent Scully. I can’t believe I’m

meeting the real people behind those great agents in the

film. Tell me, how are things with you and that handsome

boss of yours?”

Scully shot a quick look at her partner. “There are some

things on film that aren’t true in life.”

Clarissa smiled knowingly. “I’m sure.” She took her hand

from Scully’s and stretched it out toward Mulder. “It was a

pleasure to meet you, Fox.”

“Pleasure’s all mine,” he told her. “And thanks for the

heads-up on this case.”

“Don’t mention it. Hey, I live in the apartment overhead.

I hope you might stop by while you’re here. I suppose I’m

being selfish, but can I expect to see you again?”

“You just never know,” Scully replied, using her hand to

turn her partner toward the door.


The Shady Rest Bed And Breakfast Inn loomed like a

skyscraper as Mulder and Scully left the Post Office.

Directly across the road, the old hotel was framed nicely

by huge maple trees whose multitudinous leaves were already

beginning their change to the rich reds and golds of


The inn had received its renovations well. Painted white,

and its windows trimmed in navy blue and matching shutters,

it stood out in the small hamlet like a human among

zombies. The FBI agents stared at it as they waited for

several vehicles to pass on the fairly busy road.

“I’ll bet the Shady Rest once had balconies or outside

walkways,” Mulder observed.

“You could ask Clarissa.”

He laughed and shook his head. “I want to live to see



“I knew you’d think so.” He donned his sunglasses.

“You know, Mulder, I think you’re on the Internet entirely

too much. What did you do –advertise yourself in

cyberspace after that film came out? ‘Step right this way,

folks. Have the *real* Fox Mulder solve all your paranormal

problems’? Even before that. All these women you meet

through email. It’s scary, Mulder.”

“You’re just jealous.”

“Of what?”

“Of the fact that even via modems, women can’t get enough

of me.”

Scully coughed, hiding a laugh behind her hand. “Guess

I’ll find a man on the Net for me.”

“Don’t bother.” His hand went to the small of her back,

guiding her into the street so they could quickly cross.

His hand then moved to her waist and gave it a slight

squeeze. “Anyone who saw ‘The Lazarus Bowl’ knows you have

your guy. Assistant Director Walter Skinner.” He quickly

sidestepped her vengeful swipe, then jogged to the Shady

Rest’s front door and opened it for her.

Scully’s expression showed she was desperately trying to

suppress her own smile as she walked past him. “You wait,

Mulder. I’ll get you for that.”

Inside, a large registration counter was the focal point.

Its polished oak grain and floral carvings were from a

time of proud craftsmanship. A petite woman sitting behind

the counter, looked up from a ledger on which she’d been

writing. Thin, wiry, and blond, she nervously said,

“Welcome to the Shady Rest. Can I help you?”

Mulder pulled his I.D. from inside his suit coat. “Sheila

Morgan?” When she nodded, he continued. “We’re Agents

Mulder and Scully of the FBI. We heard about some problems

here, and we’d like to help.”

“FBI?” The woman’s expression contorted into a grimace,

then quickly returned to forced politeness. “Are you based

in Buffalo? Did the state troopers call you in?”

“No, ma’am.” Mulder noticed the wariness in her eyes.

“We’re from Washington, D.C. One of your neighbors

contacted me about the murders.”

“‘One of my neighbors’? Who?”

“I don’t think it’s necessary to tell…”

“Clarissa McKinnie, right? I recognize your names now.

She’s been talking about that film since she saw it. I wish

she’d mind her own damn business.”

“Apparently she felt the mystery needs to be solved.”

Mulder ran a finger along the polished oak counter top.

“Murder in a small town is everybody’s business, isn’t it?”

“Everything in a small town is everyone’s business. That’s

one thing I hate about small towns. At least a city allows

people to be anonymous.”

“Why would you want to be anonymous?” Scully asked her.

“Do you have something to hide?”

“Me? No, of course not. But I hate this community knowing

every time I breathe. Try living here a few days; you’ll

find out exactly what I mean.”

“Is your husband here?” Mulder interrupted, changing the

subject before Scully could launch into her own criticisms

of small towns.

The woman hesitated, unprepared for the abrupt switch.

“No. Bruce has gone to Buffalo today to get some supplies.”

“Long drive. We just came from the airport,” Mulder told


“Not that long. Hour and a half. If you live out here, you

come to expect long drives if you want to get anywhere.”

“I suppose you would. You’re from Buffalo originally?”

“Yes, and a few dozen other places. We’ve lived in

Syracuse, Albany, Poughkeepsie, Rochester, the City…”

“Why so many?” Scully asked.

“Why not?” Sheila Morgan flipped a strand of her long,

blond hair behind her shoulder. “We don’t like to stay in

one place long. It gets boring.”

“Then why did you come out here? It’s a bit different than

your previous experience. And Belcan’s atmosphere doesn’t

strike me as exciting,” Scully told her. “I’m sure that for

whatever it must have cost to redo this place, you could

have remodeled another or even built a new inn near a city.”

Sheila pursed her lips, ready to argue, but then she

sighed. “It was Bruce’s idea. He was sick of city living.

Said he wanted fresh air and a slower lifestyle. We came

out here a few years ago to one of their craft fairs. He

fell in love with the place.”

Scully folded her arms. “You didn’t?”

Sheila shrugged. “Where Bruce goes, I follow. It could be

worse. I get along.”

“Or at least you did until the ghost showed up…” Mulder


“That ghost,” Sheila muttered, her eyes cast down. “I

thought it was all myth until I heard it.”

“Care to tell us more about that?” Scully asked.

Mrs. Morgan favored her skeptically. “Bruce and I were in

bed one night, and we–just heard him. Doors closing, pots

and pans rattling, footsteps in the hallway. And we were

the only ones here at the time. No guests. Doors locked. It

was awful. But Bruce said I’d get used to it, and I did.

Until the murders…”

“Mrs. McKinnie says that you both had an alibi for each

night of the murders; is that correct?”

“Y-yes. We went out with friends to eat in Wellston. It’s

the *only* town in the county that has anything to do. We

went to a restaurant, and afterward, we went to the movies.

Each of those nights, we didn’t get home till around 2:30


“Long movies,” Scully commented.

“The movies ended around 11:30,” Sheila sneered, “and we

went for ice cream afterward. And then back to their home

to talk. The police have checked all this out; you can

contact them. Waiters and waitresses confirmed our being

there, as did our credit card receipts. Besides, you think

we’d jeopardize our own business? You think we’d kill our

own guests?” Her hard stare at Scully was a mixture of

resentment and pain.

“Well, someone wants to kill your guests.”

“It’s not us, I assure you.”

“Have the police suggested shutting down the hotel?”

Mulder asked.

“Yes. But Bruce wouldn’t hear of it. We’ve no proof that

it’s not someone in the community who’s just jealous that

we’re making money. No one else in this town has a cent.

And the inn was empty for nearly forty years; maybe someone

had a secret way into it.”

“And you think these townspeople are coming in now to…

what — frame you?” Scully asked.

“That would get rid of us, wouldn’t it?”

“You think they want to get rid of you?”

“It wouldn’t surprise me. They’re not happy to have city

folk among them. They’re all right to our faces, but we’ve

heard talk of how we don’t fit in. And now, they’re taking

advantage of the fact that the ghost lives here, and

they’re exploiting him — and us.”

“But you’ve no proof of that,” Scully observed.

Sheila’s shrug was confirmation.

“Could we see the inn?” Mulder asked.

“You gonna stay overnight here?”

“We don’t usually stay in a spot we’re investigating.”

“Then you got a warrant?”

Mulder sighed. “Mrs. Morgan, parts of this hotel have been

a crime scene. And Agent Scully and I *are* from the FBI.

If there’s nothing to incriminate you here, then why would

we need a warrant? We want to see where the murders were

committed to get a better idea of who — or what– might be


Sheila bit off a remaining piece of nail from her

forefinger. Mulder noticed that she’d chewed all her nails

to beneath her fingertips.

“You can accompany us to the rooms,” Scully offered.

Sheila snorted sarcastically and eyed Scully with disdain.

“And leave the front desk?”

Mulder glanced at the large, oaken lobby and its plush,

maroon carpet. To the right were stairs and a door that

opened into a small, abundantly stocked craft shop. He

could see stuffed ghosts, and T-shirts, place mats, and post

cards printed with the Shady Rest’s logo or photo. To his

left was a door to a nicely furnished dining room. But the

inn seemed empty of other customers.

“Mrs. Morgan, certainly if a customer was to come in,

you’d be able to hear him?” Mulder asked.

Sheila looked at her watch. “Well, it’s nearly 4:30.

People may start arriving any minute now.”

“Are you afraid to go up there?” Scully asked. “Are you

afraid you’ll see the ghost yourself?”

Sheila stiffened. “Of course not.” She looked at both

agents and then reached below the counter for a set of

keys. “Fine. But I want you to leave if…well, if I say

you should. Otherwise, I’ll call 911, and the troopers will

move you out.”

“Okay.” Mulder tossed a glance at Scully as he followed

Sheila to the stairs. His partner’s gaze showed him she

felt as he did about their hostess.

“All three murders were committed on the second floor,”

Sheila said over her shoulder. “Bruce and I keep the third

floor for ourselves, and you’re not going up there without

a warrant.”

“Mrs. Morgan,” Scully asked, taking the steps carefully,

“what’s on the first floor other than the lobby and craft


“The dining room, obviously. And the kitchen. Our supply


“And the second floor is strictly rooms for rent?” Mulder



“Is there a basement as well?”

“Of course. But it’s a mess. Bruce and I plan to clean it

out someday; the inn takes priority.”

Sheila reached the first landing of the wide staircase.

“Originally, there were twelve rooms on the second floor,

three on each wall. Bruce and I had the four middle rooms

redone to serve as bathrooms for the rooms that bordered

them. So in other words, now just eight rooms are available

to the public.”

Mulder pulled at his lower lip with his thumb and

forefinger. “Must have been quite a bill in an old place

like this.”

Sheila nodded, allowing a small smile at what she

perceived to be his appreciation. “Sure was.”

“May I ask what you and your husband have done throughout

your careers?” Scully asked.

Suddenly, Sheila’s pride disappeared. She turned, her gaze

darting from one FBI agent to the other. “Wh-What do you


“What work did you do? How could you afford the money to

remodel this place so extensively?”

Sheila resumed her climb, her plaid skirt swishing about

her calves. “We’ve always run motels. But we did *this*

with an inheritance,” she murmured. “A long lost relative


Behind her, Mulder and Scully once again exchanged looks,

and he gestured for her to precede him.

“You can’t believe this ghost story, Mulder,” Scully

whispered as she passed him. “Nothing ghostly is happening

here. I *do* think there’s something shady about the Shady

Rest, though. And it’s not just the trees.” She turned

before she saw her partner nod his agreement.


Room 25 overlooked the main part of Belcan. Mulder stood

at the window, holding back maroon drapes and seeing Mel

Barker’s rig parked on an unmown lawn about a block away.

He could read the “Crown Industries” lettering and see its

logo on the side of the long trailer. The clipping Clarissa

McKinnie had sent him reported that Barker had suffered

over twenty-five stab wounds to his body — ten of which

could have been fatal. Poor Mel had come across the country

on a hectic run to be murdered in a tiny hamlet. It struck

Mulder that someone working for a company called “Crown”

deserved a more regal end.

Scully and Sheila Morgan continued to talk about position

of the body and other details, but Mulder ignored them.

Barker’s room had, of course, been cleaned, and for all

Mulder knew, the Morgans may have rented it since Mel’s

death. But he absorbed the room around him anyway. Fake oak

paneling covered two of the inner walls, and cream

wallpaper with tiny maroon flowers adorned the outer wall.

The room was fairly large and square, and its fourth side

held a built-in closet and the bathroom door.

The bathroom was fairly spacious, and the floor was white

tile linoleum. Mulder carefully leaned across the set-in

bathtub, expertly running his hands around the tile walls.

Feeling no breaks — no way for any of the tiles to be

easily removed and then replaced — he opened a narrow

linen closet, finding it well-stocked with clean towels,

washcloths, and sample toiletries. The ceiling, done in

white wallpaper, also held no breaks.

Mulder left the bathroom, finding that Scully and Sheila

had exited the room and were discussing the other rooms in

which murders had occurred. He ignored their conversation

once more and turned to the built-in closet, opening its

two doors. He pulled a flashlight from his pocket and began

to inspect its inner walls.


“The other murders occurred in Rooms 26 and 28,” Sheila

was saying. “Those rooms don’t look any different than 25.”

“And what was the manner of death for each murder?” Scully

stopped outside 26 which was on the same wall as 25. She

placed her hands on her hips. “Were both of the other

victims stabbed to death?”

“No.” Sheila’s jaw set. “Look, why don’t you and your

partner go to Wellston and talk to the troopers? Or go to

the county seat and talk to the sheriff? You could get

their reports, and I could get back to work.”

“We’ll probably do that. But surely you could tell me how

the others were killed.”

Mrs. Morgan sighed heavily. “The first one was beaten to

death, and the other was strangled.”

“And the police have no motives?”

“Nope. The first guy was a private detective — his name

was J.J. Austin — and the cops thought maybe the murderer

was whoever he was looking into. But nobody in this

community had hired the guy or was being investigated by

him. The second man was an arrogant creep — a salesman.

His name was Byrd. I doubt that anyone even misses him.”

“I’d like to see the other rooms, please.” Mulder

surprised them as he exited Room 25.

“They look just alike.”

“I want to see them.” He saw Sheila Morgan cower at his

tone, and he followed as she inserted a key into the lock

of Room 26.

Just then they heard the inn’s main door open.

“Oh! I have to go — there’s a customer…” Sheila looked

torn between whether to stay with the agents or to return

to her duties.

“Go ahead. I just want a look,” Mulder told her.

“I’d rather you wouldn’t while I’m not here.”

“Then consider this room — and number 25 — taken for the

night. Agent Scully and I *will* be staying.”

Sheila nodded uncomfortably. She quickly glanced inside

the room and then nervously scurried past the agents and

down the stairs.

“When did you decide this, Mulder?” Scully asked.

“I don’t think we have a choice, Scully. We *have* to see

this ghost ourselves, don’t you think?”

“You know what happened the last time we saw ghosts.”

“Or thought we did.”

She smiled and shook her head. “You know, Sheila Morgan

isn’t going to win any Miss Congeniality awards. I can’t

tell if she’s just scared or hiding something. Either way,

I think she knows a lot more than she’s saying.”

Mulder had already entered the room. “I think she could

tell us lots of things, Scully. But I’d rather have that

conversation with her husband. C’mere. I want to show you




8:50 p.m., August 25

Near the Shady Rest

“Chips, please.” Scully was propped on her elbow on the

gravel shore of the Genesee River. Before her, an unfolded

newspaper lay beneath a can of iced tea and a Styrofoam

plate holding half of a turkey sub. A little beyond her

reach were several file folders, papers sticking past their


Mulder passed her the bag of potato chips with one hand

while holding his own sandwich to his mouth. He had another

file folder balanced on one knee. He sat on the shore,

dressed in jeans and a sweatshirt, feeling too warm on this

mild August night. His gaze wandered over Scully’s legs —

which stretched from beige shorts. He could see the bandage

covering the flesh wound she’d received during the previous

case. And he smiled at the “Shady Rest: The Haunted Inn” T-

shirt he’d bought and insisted that she wear for the

evening. On it, the image of a cartoon ghost rose amicably

past a sketch of the Shady Rest.

Pinks and oranges of the sunset reflected in the rippling

river. Mulder stared at the sight while he finished his

iced tea, then took another can from the plastic ring of

the six-pack.

“Want another one, Scully?”

“Not yet, thanks.” She munched a chip and then looked up

at her partner. In the dusk’s tones, he appeared more tan

and younger. But the look she knew so well was in his eyes.

Mulder was on the hunt; nothing excited him more than a new


“So what do you think?” he asked her, indicating the file

folders with the hand that held his sandwich.

“I think you did a lot of research before we got here. I

think you called people all over this state without letting

me know you were onto something. I think you’ve been in

contact with the New York State Troopers for weeks, maybe


“And you’re not disagreeing with me? I’m turned on by

that, Scully.”

She nodded. “I think you have this case solved, and I

really don’t know why we’re here, Mulder.”

He grinned. “You wanna know why we *really* came?”

“Other than to meet Clarissa?”

“Yeah, other than that.” He swallowed a bite of sandwich.

“I knew it was the only way you’d rest. I thought we’d have

fun and get a little R & R.”

“What rest will I get if what you have planned for tonight

takes place?”

“I wasn’t necessarily anticipating that.”

“I’m still not so sure we should do *that* without a

warrant anyway. But then, since when have you played by the


Mulder sobered. “Well, playing by the rules got someone

killed.” When he noticed that he’d caused his partner to

sober, too, he grabbed the bag of chips from her. “Enough

of these, Scully. You’ll lose your great figure.”

“Since when have you worried about my ‘great’ figure?”

“Since about twenty minutes ago when you began devouring

these *and* a turkey sub.”

“Thanks for your concern.”


Scully stretched her free arm toward the sky, a yawn

escaping her lips. “It’s pleasant here. Too bad we can’t go

for a swim.”

“Would be nice. But that water’s not clean. You don’t need

some infection in those wounds.”

Scully sat up. “Forget about my wounds, would you, please?

I’ve had far worse.”

He nodded as he finished his sandwich. He noticed that

Scully was done with hers, too. “You think Bruce Morgan

might be back from Buffalo yet?”

“Probably.” She looked toward Belcan, only two blocks

away. She could see the Shady Rest’s roof from her seat on

the gravel. “Meeting him will be interesting.”

“Yeah, I’m looking forward to it.” He stood, drinking the

last sip from his newly opened can of tea, and tucking

garbage into the grocery bag in which their purchases had

been packed. Then he extended a hand and pulled Scully to

her feet. He intertwined his fingers with hers as they bade

a silent good night to the softly rippling river bathed in

sunset hues.


“Agents Mulder and Scully, I presume.”

The man who approached them as they entered the Shady

Rest’s well-lit lobby, was tall, balding, and chubby. He

stretched out a hand to Scully and smiled. In his mid-

forties, he displayed none of his wife’s nervousness, and

his handshake was nearly bone-crushing. Scully tried to

read his eyes, but they had already focused on Mulder.

“Bruce Morgan?” Mulder stated more than asked.

“One and the same, sir. It’s nice to meet you both. My

wife tells me that someone in the neighborhood aroused your

suspicions about our establishment. I’m more than happy to

cooperate if there’s anything you’d like to know.”

“Actually, there’s quite a bit we’d like to know,” Mulder


Morgan gestured to a maroon couch and chair that were off

to the lobby’s side. As the agents moved toward the seats,

another man who’d been reading a newspaper there rose,

folding the paper and tucking it beneath his arm.

“I’m sorry, Mr. Allen. I didn’t realize you were here,”

Morgan said, his voice full and loud.

“Um…that’s quite all right,” Mr. Allen replied softly.

He was short, in his 60s, and scrawny. Dressed in a black

business suit, his thinning, white hair neatly combed, he

bit his lower lip and shuffled past the Shady Rest’s big


“Mr. Allen’s our only other guest tonight,” Morgan told

Mulder and Scully. “And Mr. Allen, these are FBI agents

from Washington, D.C.”

Allen’s head lifted as the introductions were made. Scully

stifled a gasp as she saw a deep scar lining the right side

of the man’s face — the result of an injury obviously

suffered long ago. His right eye was covered by a milky

blue film. She shook his hand, muttering, “Nice to meet


Mulder was saying the same, and if he was shocked by the

scarring, he didn’t show it.

“Nice to meet you as well. I assume you’re just passing

through?” the little man asked.

“Well…” Scully looked at Morgan whose face nearly

pleaded with her not to mention the murders. “Our visit is


“Oh.” Mr. Allen was unimpressed. He turned to his host.

“My bags?”

“Yes, sir, you’ll find them and extra towels in Room 21.”

“Very good. A pleasant evening to all,” Allen murmured as

he slowly headed up the stairs.

Morgan chuckled. “Strange man — the type I need to see

after a trip to Buffalo.”

“Yes, Buffalo,” Scully said, “that’s one thing we’d like

to talk to you about. May I ask, for instance, what

supplies you need to travel so far to get?”

Morgan gestured for her to sit on the couch. “Sheila needs

various things for her crafts.” He sat in the chair facing

the couch, and continued after Mulder sat across from him.

“And we get paper goods in bulk from a warehouse supplier.

Much less expensive than most places around here. And once

a month I go there to stock up. Today was my ‘once a month’


“Must be a good supplier. Our research shows that you’ve

journeyed to Buffalo once a month for several years — from

all over the state. Do you go alone?”

“A friend goes with me,” Morgan replied, an eyebrow raised.

Mulder nodded. “Mr. Morgan, if I may, I’d like to ask you

a few questions about the Shady Rest and your past.”

Morgan’s smile remained on his lips. “Of course. Anything

I can do to help the FBI.”

“And to solve the murders, I would assume,” Scully

reminded him.

“Oh, absolutely. Of course.”

“Mr. Morgan,” Mulder started, “the murders took place in

three different rooms?”

“Yes. When the first one occurred in Room 28, we decided

that we wouldn’t rent it out to guests again. But then in

April, the guest was killed in 26, and then just a week or

so ago, the murder happened in 25.”

“You’ve no theory on these murders, sir?”

Morgan shrugged, his hands raised to shoulder level. “The

ghost. That’s the only way I can explain it. Sheila and I

were away.”

“Yes, we’ve already heard about that,” Scully replied.

“What about your friend, Mr. Morgan? Does he have a key to

the Shady Rest?”

“Friend? Oh, no, he doesn’t. Nor does our help. Sheila and

I both have a key. That’s it.”

“And what time do you lock the doors?” Mulder asked.

“Usually at 10 p.m. We ask all our guests to be in by that

time. We stay in the lobby until 11, though, just in case

someone’s late.”

“Have any of your guests ever brought other people in —

maybe that you didn’t okay?” Scully asked.

“No. Most of our customers are truck drivers or salesmen

who just want to stay overnight. There aren’t many motels

in the area, and this is a major route to Buffalo from this

county. Most of the time, a person passing through will

stop and be gone the next morning.” Morgan shifted his

shoulders. “Of course, we hope that they’ll pass on word of

the Shady Rest, and that soon we will have vacationers

staying with us.”

“For what?” Scully wanted to know. “What’s around here?”

“A state park, colleges, and universities. The area is

rich in Indian history; it was a stop on the Underground

Railroad. And, of course, until ol’ Cecil started killing

people, we were hoping to appeal to the more — how should

I say it? Mystical vacationers. People who’d want to stay

in a haunted hotel.”

“You don’t think shutting the place down ’til ‘ol’ Cecil’

is exorcize is a good idea?” Scully asked.

“No,” Morgan returned seriously. “It’s our bread and

butter, Agent Scully. Rebuilding this place wasn’t cheap,

and running it isn’t cheap either. We can’t take a loss

because some ghost comes out of the woodwork.”

“Who are your other employees?”

Morgan smoothed a crease in his navy blue slacks. “We’ve

three women who work here during the day. Heather Pearce is

our waitress. She’s only part time. Laura Kiefer is our

cook — again, only morning help. And Cynthia Katz. She

spends a lot of time on the floor.” He chuckled as if this

might be a private joke. “She’s our full-time maid. We have

her clean every room daily, whether it was rented or not.”

“You wouldn’t suspect any of them?”

“Agent Scully, you’ve seen this town. How many employment

possibilities are there? These fine ladies are grateful for

their jobs.”

“Okay.” Scully looked toward her partner.

“I don’t believe I caught your friend’s name,” Mulder

said, meeting her gaze, and prompting Morgan. “The one who

accompanies you to Buffalo.”

“Does it matter?” Morgan shrugged. “He lives nearby. We

call him Lenny. I’ve known him… um…since we’ve been

here. He wouldn’t have any grudges against us, I’m sure.”

“Mr. Morgan, I’ve checked into your history somewhat,”

Mulder said, placing the file folders on the coffee table

that separated him and Scully from their host. “Your

inheritance — which your wife told us about this afternoon

— actually came upon the death of your younger brother.”

Morgan’s head tipped toward his lap. He brought a hand up

to shield his eyes. “Yes.”

“He died in a fire?”

“A theater fire, yes. In Poughkeepsie — a regional

theater. He was trying to save the director — that’s what

the investigators decided.” He took a deep breath. “This is

not easy to talk about.”

“Your brother’s name was Charles?”

“Charlie. Charles, of course. Yes.”

“He had quite a past,” Mulder observed. He opened one of

the folders. Shuffling a few papers to the front, he read,

then commented, “Charlie lived in New York City for several

years. Started as a stage hand and worked up to acting.

Says here that he was one of the main stars of an off-

Broadway actors’ group — the Academy Arts Theater Company

on East 57th.”

“Yes, the AATC. Those were his best years.” Morgan looked

up, his eyes dry.

“He quit in…”

“Yes, he quit. Acting doesn’t pay many bills, especially

in the City. Even back then — in the ’70s — apartment rent

was sky-high. He came upstate. My parents and us — we

lived in Syracuse then. He got a teaching job at a high

school — English ‘lit’ and drama. He was excellent at it.”

“But he quit that, too — after four years?” Mulder


“It wasn’t the same for him. He lived to act.”

“And then there seems to have been some sort of mental


Morgan sat up straighter in his chair. “Where are you

getting all this information from?” His voice became less


Mulder shrugged. “Police record. Some other government

documents. Phone calls here and there.”

Morgan leaned forward. “How long have you been doing

this… research?”

“Does it matter?”

Morgan took a deep breath. As he exhaled, he said, “My

brother had a nervous breakdown. He became a recluse as he

underwent therapy.”

“And tried to act again.”

“And assaulted a director in a podunk town — for which he

was arrested and fined. Yes, I know these things.”

“Assaulted him… and then later tried to save him in that

fire?” Mulder asked.

Morgan stood, turned his back on them, and thrust his

hands into his pants pockets. His body seemed to shudder.

“Agents, my brother is dead. He’s been dead since 1992.

What does any of this have to do with the murders at the

Shady Rest?”

“You’re right.” Mulder also stood. “Sorry. Just got

carried away. Your brother’s history fascinated me; such a

great talent laid to waste.”

Morgan nodded. “Well, tomorrow we can talk again.”

“Count on it,” Mulder replied. “Scully? Ready?”

“Yes. Good night, Mr. Morgan. And thank you.”

“If we can find some way to get rid of Cecil, I’m willing

to help you all I can.” Morgan looked at his watch and

moved behind the registration desk. “It’s late. See you in

the morning. Breakfast starts at 8.”

Mulder waited for Scully to take the stairs ahead of him

so that her ear would be near his lips as he whispered,

“And off we go to a shady rest, indeed.”


3:10 a.m. August 26

Room 25, Shady Rest

“You’re late.”

“Sorry, Mulder. The alarm clock is slow.”

“Always an excuse, Scully. You *did* sleep?”

“Of course. You didn’t?” She stepped from the dim hallway

and watched her partner as he closed the door behind her.

“Nah. I had to stay awake in case ‘ol’ Cecil’ came after


“Yeah, that’s what Cecil’s planning.” She sat on Mulder’s

bed. “So have you heard ‘the ghost?'”

Mulder smiled. “Yeah, as a matter of fact.”

“Really? I didn’t think he’d be around tonight.”

“Footsteps in the hallway. I opened the door, but saw

nothing. A few minutes later, this light,” he indicated the

bedstand’s lamp, “flashed on and off and then back on. I

even heard a few doors open and close. But not yours,

Scully, so I wasn’t too worried.”

“You’re kidding, right?” She looked closely at him,

failing to find his usual smirk.

“No, I’m really not joking. And I can’t explain it. Was it

a ghost? Or just someone trying to make it seem like one?

That’s for them to know and for us to find out.”

Scully noticeably shuddered. “Okay, now I *am* shaking in

my high heels. Dark building where murders have been

committed. Ghostly noises at night. Mulder, you must have

been a hoot at Boy Scout camp.”

“I was an Indian Guide, Scully.”


“Shhhh!” Mulder suddenly stopped her, his finger to his

lips. “Hear that?”

Scully’s eyes widened. “What?”

“Nothing. Made you listen, though,” he laughed.

“Mulder, sometimes I really hate you.” She stood and

started toward his closet.

“You’re not really wearing high heels, are you, Scully?”

He leaned over to look at her feet beneath her black slacks.

“You’re always concerned about the most important

details,” she replied. “Actually, I’m wearing very quiet


“Good. But they make you a lot shorter.”

“Keep it up, Mulder, and I’ll point ol’ Cecil to this room.”

“Shhh!” Again, his finger went to his lips.



Because of the look on her partner’s face, Scully

listened. Unmistakingly, there were footsteps on the

stairs. Slow. Deliberate. Footsteps. “Mulder,” she

whispered quickly, “let me look.” She started to the door.

“No, Scully, if that’s him, then now’s our time to get

moving. C’mon.” He led her back to the closet which he

opened noiselessly. “Got your flashlight?”

“Of course.” She shone it for him as he began to remove a

piece of paneling from the back wall. “I still don’t know

how the police could have missed this. They couldn’t have

looked too closely.”

“Three murders… they should have scoured the place.”

Mulder reached behind the paneling to dislodge a stay. “But

then we wouldn’t have been able to come to Belcan.”

“True. And what a miss that would have been.”

With a slight click, the paneling came away from the wall,

revealing a dark opening. A musty smell greeted their

noses, and when Scully shone the flashlight into the

blackness, they saw a landing between rooms 25 and 26, and

a shaft into which a ladder descended.

“I always thought walking through walls was easy for

ghosts, but Cecil must do things the hard way,” Mulder


“Cecil or someone who wants ghosts to seem real.”

“I’ll go first.” Mulder used his own flashlight and guided

its beam over the floor of the cavern. “It’s spotless. No

footprints in dust. Heck, no dust.”

“Cecil’s a clean ghost.”

“Yeah, right.” Mulder moved into the hidden room and

trained his flashlight on the area below. “This shaft goes

all the way to the basement. But there are two ladders. One

must stop at the first floor. Must be an opening into the

gift shop.”

“Mulder! I hear footsteps.” Scully motioned him back into

his room. “Hurry!”

He joined her, and they quickly put the paneling back over

the hole, then stood quietly.

“Agent Mulder?” The voice in the hallway was hushed and

easily recognizable.

Mulder looked at Scully who was staring at him

quizzically. He left the closet, closing the doors softly,

and leaving her behind them. He opened the door of his

room. “Mrs. Morgan?”

Sheila wore a full-length, white terrycloth robe which

dwarfed her. The lit candle she carried sent eerie shadows

over her face.

“I saw your light,” she murmured. “I wanted to be sure you

were…all right.”

“Afraid the ghost might have gotten me?”

“Afraid that maybe you were afraid to sleep,” she replied.

“We sell over-the-counter sleeping pills in the gift shop.”

He shook his head. “No, I’m fine, thanks. Just going over

some files.”

“You’re a workaholic. And an insomniac.”

Mulder was surprised by her suddenly friendly manner.

Apparently, Sheila Morgan wasn’t always the timid yet

ornery person she’d seemed in the afternoon. “I guess you

could say that. You’re not much of a sleeper yourself, I

take it.”

She peered into his room, then focused on him again. “I

don’t sleep well. Not since all of this started.”

“All of what? The murders or something else?”

“You’re still dressed.” She nervously smiled at him. “I’ll

let you get back to work. You should get some sleep,

though. Goodnight.” She hurried to the door that led to the

third floor’s stairway, and was out of sight in seconds.

Mulder watched after her, then closed his own door,

wondering about her words. He returned to the closet. “Did

you hear all of that, Scully?”

But when he peered inside, the paneling had again been

removed. And Scully was no longer there.


Mulder shivered in instant panic. He quickly entered the

hidden room, shining his flashlight into the ladder shaft.

He could see no one, no glint reflecting off the lovely red

silk of Scully’s hair. He tried to calm himself, to think

before doing anything rash. Impulsively rushing into action

wasn’t one of his better traits.

He held a deep breath and listened. He heard footsteps

overhead; Sheila Morgan had returned to Bruce. He wanted

Scully to return to him.

He mounted the ladder. The wood was sturdy, its paint

fairly new. He began a slow, quiet descent, taking one step

and then shining the flashlight below him in case he could

see movement.

Scary thoughts flashed through his mind. Of Scully in the

hands of a murderer. Of her being stabbed repeatedly. Of

her being strangled. He’d seen the results of real violence

wreaked on her body and mind, and such memories haunted him

in nightmares still.

He took his fifth step. Suddenly, a horrendous boom

resounded above him as if something massive had fallen — a

sound distant but thunderous. And it had definitely

happened on the second floor.

For an instant, Mulder wondered whether to continue his

journey or to rush toward the sound. He couldn’t leave

Scully, but he couldn’t be sure the boom hadn’t involved

her. What if something had been dropped on her? Or she’d

been thrown against a wall or…

He was already stepping off the top rung of the ladder.

Suddenly, he sensed movement. Something drove into his

torso and knocked him into the wall with a force that sent

him to the floor. His side screamed in pain, and his hands

instinctively pressed against his ribs. Breathing was

difficult; the wind had been knocked out of him. And his

flashlight had been knocked from his hand.

Whatever had hit him was now on top of him. The weight was

not much, but it had him pinned. Not being able to gasp a

breath, he found struggling against his captor nearly

impossible. But he wriggled — only to receive what he was

sure was an elbow to his jaw. His head flew backwards,

hitting the floor with a crack that sent glittering

pinpoints behind his closed eyelids.

“Federal Agent! Lay still, moron! I’m armed!”

Mulder blinked. He stared up toward the voice. The hidden

room was dark, but he’d left the panel off the back of his

closet. The light from his room touched a few silken

strands of red hair.


“Oh, my God. Mulder?”

The weight quickly left his chest, and she tugged him into

a sitting position.

“Mulder, what were you doing? I didn’t know that was you.”

“Scully, where did you go?” He struggled to take deep

breaths. “I thought… I thought he had you.”

“Cell phone, Mulder. While you and Sheila were chatting, I

found I’d left it in my room. Going through the panels was

a lot less obvious.”

He shook his head, trying to get what were now silver

streaks to leave his vision. “I was worried, Scully.”

She touched his shoulder. “Are you all right? Did I hurt


“Nothing a few weeks in the hospital won’t fix.” He shook

off her hand, cocking his head toward the hallway.


Footsteps were flying down the stairs.

“Where was it?” Bruce Morgan’s voice leapt at them through

the walls.

“I don’t know!!” Sheila yelled. “Agent Mulder! Come

quickly!! We think there’s been another murder!”

Mulder started up, discovering that his ribs were bruised

more than he’d thought. He winced with pain.

“You okay, Mulder?” Scully asked.

He muttered a doubtful “yeah” as he ushered her through

the passage. Then, holding his arm against his aching side,

he followed Scully into the now brightly lit hallway.



4:25 a.m., August 26 Room 21, Shady Rest

Mulder’s long legs quickly took him across the foyer to

Room 21. He ignored his screaming ribs; he would deal with

them later.

Sheila Morgan stood behind her husband, her hands clasped

over her mouth; her eyes, wide in terror. Her long, white

robe was tied tightly around her tiny figure, and it swayed

against her legs, slow to calm after her run to this room.

Bruce Morgan struggled with a key, trying to unlock the

door as fast as he could. His hands, however, shook, and

Mulder, his gun in a safe but ready position, moved to take


“Sheila, go back. I don’t want you to see it this time,”

Morgan said as allowed Mulder to turn the doorknob to Mr.

Allen’s room.

“Your husband’s right, Mrs. Morgan,” Mulder told her in

the calmest voice he could muster. “Go back to my room and

just wait.” He turned, forcing her to meet his gaze. He

waited until her terrified eyes saw him nod, and then she

shuffled toward Room 25, her hands still over her mouth.

She didn’t close his room’s door.

Mulder aimed as he opened Room 21. “Federal Agent! I’m

armed!” He managed to click on the ceiling light switch

with his elbow.

Seeing no one in the room, Mulder and Scully edged further

inside. Scully quickly moved to the open closet doors, but

the false panel had already been replaced. She next moved

to the bathroom, finding it empty as well.

“Oh, my God. Not again.” Bruce Morgan stood behind them,

staring at the center of the room.

Scully and Mulder followed his gaze and eased their aims.

Mr. Allen was nowhere in sight. But the big double mattress

and its boxed springs were completely off the oak frame of

the bed – -and overturned on the floor. But they weren’t

laying completely flat; something was beneath them. And

because of the dark, spreading stain on the maroon carpet,

they were quite sure of Mr. Allen’s whereabouts.

Mulder and Morgan swiftly lifted the heavy bedding off the

tiny man and back onto the bed’s frame. But it was obvious

to all present that they were too late. Though Scully

checked him for vitals, Mr. Allen had been suffocated and

crushed; Mulder wasn’t sure in which order. The dead man’s

face, frozen in horror, was splattered with blood. But his

film-covered eye shone through the sticky crimson liquid

like a beacon.

Mulder’s mind raced as he turned to his partner.


But a scream interrupted him.

“NO!! Get out of here! We don’t want you here anymore!”

Sheila Morgan’s voice shrieked from Mulder’s room. Her

hysterical cries were suddenly silenced by a loud slap.

“Sheila?” Mulder yelled. He raced to his room, forcing his

body to stop before he ran over the Shady Rest’s hostess

who was on the floor in a heap, her arms wrapped around her

head. “Sheila? Did he hurt you?”

“I… can’t stand it anymore. I… want him gone.”

“Honey, hush.” Morgan knelt at his wife’s side, and his

hands went to her shoulders, urging her to get up. The

sobbing woman did so, welcoming the comforting touch. He

guided her to sit on Mulder’s bed, and continued to hold


Scully entered and noticed that Sheila’s face was bleeding

from a nasty scratch between her cheekbone and chin. She

quickly produced a wet washcloth and held it to the woman’s

face. “I called the police; they’re on their way,” Scully

told her partner.

“What? No. Please.” Morgan looked up from his wife to the

agents. “Don’t bring them here.”

Mulder met his gaze. “It’s Charlie, isn’t it? Charlie

isn’t dead.”

Sheila took over the washcloth. She looked up at Mulder

and slowly nodded.

“Sheila!” her husband protested, his expression panicked.

“He lives in the basement?” Mulder continued.

Again, Sheila nodded. “He was… he was never right again.

The nervous breakdown. He hated that director. The idiot

fired Charlie.”

“Charlie killed him, didn’t he?”

“He strangled him. And he started the fire.”

“Be quiet! Don’t tell them this!” Morgan pleaded, his face

turning red.

Scully peeled the washcloth away from the scratch to check

on it, then guided the cloth over the cut again. She

ignored Morgan. “But there were two bodies. Whose was the


“A homeless man. The play was about homeless people, and

Charlie always researched his parts. The man had no teeth.

Neither does Charlie. He got dentures so he could have a

perfect smile.”

“The bodies were burned beyond recognition,” Scully

finished for her, “and there was no way to do a dental I.D.”

Sheila nodded again. “We got the inheritance. Bruce and

Charlie had always been close. And Bruce used some of the

money to move us from place to place, hiding Charlie. That

became the prime goal of our marriage — to hide Charlie.”

Morgan rose, trying to intimidate his wife with his

towering presence. “If you don’t shut up…”

“Charlie goes to Buffalo with you, doesn’t he?” Mulder

asked the irate man.

“Yes. Charlie’s psychiatrist is there,” Sheila answered

for her husband. “She’s put him on various drug

combinations, trying to decrease his psychosis. But he just

gets worse.”

“His hallucinations… He thinks he’s still acting,

doesn’t he?”

“What? Mulder, what?” Scully looked at him.

“The first murder — that was just paranoia, wasn’t it?

J.J. Austin was a private detective who Charlie thought was

looking for him.”

Sheila nearly whispered. “Charlie thought he was Hercule


Morgan reeled. “I don’t believe you’re doing this! Shut up!”

“The second murder — Mr. Byrd,” Mulder continued,

watching Bruce from the corner of his eye. “He was

strangled in a strange way — with a rope while he was in

bed. In Poughkeepsie, Charlie was in a production of

‘Trifles’, Susan Glaspell’s play about a husband strangled

in his bed by his wife — because the guy killed her


Sheila’s hands dropped to her lap. “Charlie was so good in

that. He played the sheriff.”

“What about Mel Barker?” Scully prompted her partner.

“Crown Industries. He was stabbed to death in bed. I’m

guessing that’s from ‘Macbeth’ — where Macbeth kills King

Duncan to satisfy his own ambition — and to become king


“And tonight’s murder?”

“The eye,” Mulder murmured. “‘The Tell-Tale Heart’.”

Scully nodded. “Look, we have to stop Charlie. Is he in

the basement?”

“You won’t take my brother,” Morgan avowed.

Sheila turned mournful eyes to him, though speaking to

Scully. “He could be anywhere in this hotel. He has a

network of secret passageways. They date from the

Civil War and the Underground Railroad. That was one

of the reasons Bruce chose this place. He figured Charlie

wouldn’t get bored. You can get to them through the


“We’ve already found those. Does he ever go to the third


“No. Because of me. He stopped liking me when he heard us

arguing about moving here. I hated the idea, but Bruce

insisted. And Charlie always sides with Bruce. Bruce

thought that being a ghost by night would be a perfect job

for Charlie. What better to bring in the tourists than a

great actor playing a ghost? Charlie was wonderful at

first, but then he just — just got into the part too much.”

“Sheila!! Will you shut the hell up?! So help me…”

“Hey,” Mulder cautioned, struggling to draw Morgan to the

doorway, “you’ve no choice but to end this. You’re in

enough trouble.”

Morgan put his hands on Mulder’s shoulders, impatiently

imploring understanding. His voice was higher-pitched in

his hysteria. “Look, my brother’s a good man. And this…

can be our secret. The Troopers will come; we’ll say it was

the ghost again. They’ll investigate as they always do,

find nothing, and in a few days, this will all wash over. I

promise I’ll take Charlie away somewhere. Please, don’t do


“I can’t and won’t do that. Help us get him. Now.”

“I have money — what will it take?”

Mulder shook his head. He moved from the man’s grasp.

Morgan howled. “NO!! Charlie!!” He quickly ran from the

room and headed down the stairs.


“Right!” Scully drew her weapon and edged toward the

closet, behind her partner. “Mrs. Morgan, I want you to go

across the street right now. Do you understand me? Go to

Clarissa McKinnie’s apartment. Stay there until we come to

get you.”

Sheila looked dazed. “Bruce…?”

“Go, now! Do you hear?” Scully persisted.

Mrs. Morgan looked from Scully to Mulder and back.

Finally, the instructions seemed to register. “Yes.” She

clutched her robe around her and ran from the room.

And as the Shady Rest’s front door opened and closed,

Mulder and Scully entered the open passage in the closet.


“Don’t know about you, Scully, but after all these years,

I’m really tired of dark rooms.”

They had descended the ladders to the cellar and had

cautiously explored the furnace and laundry rooms. Finding

no one, they’d carefully entered Charlie’s modestly-

furnished basement apartment. But the lights were off, and

Mulder and Scully continued to rely on their flashlights.

They had searched a bedroom, bathroom, and hallway,

opening doors and closets, even looking under the unmade

bed. Now, their backs against the opposing walls of a

narrow hallway, they were headed toward what had to be a

living room and kitchen.

“There could be crawl spaces above, Mulder,” Scully

whispered. “The furnace and plumbing pipes would have been

added in the remodeling. Such an old building wouldn’t have

had them originally.”

“True, but I think he’s here, waiting for us.”

“And his brother.”

Though his partner couldn’t see it, Mulder nodded in

agreement. They had reached the end of the hallway. His

weapon drawn, he took a deep breath and glanced in Scully’s

direction, somehow knowing that she mirrored his actions.

He turned his flashlight into the large area that lay

ahead, allowing a brief look at a small living room.

Mulder swung the light, searching from side to side, as

Scully also did beside him. He could see no one, but he

caught his partner glancing at him and starting to move

into the room.

Instantly, her gun and flashlight dropped to the floor.

Mulder’s light focused on a man’s left arm wrapping around

her chest and a right hand covering her mouth. “Don’t touch

her!” Mulder yelled, bursting forward without hesitation.

Suddenly, something hard cracked against his head. Silvery

shimmers returned, multiplied. His eyes squeezed shut

against the blinding agony. And his torso exploded in pain

as it met the floor, his belly-flop smacking his already

aching ribs. But more was to come. Suddenly, a foot

connected with his side. Hard. Mulder screamed as the kicks

continued, seeming to tear his skin and impact directly

with his bones. Finally, the torture stopped. He fought for

consciousness, but his numbed mind demanded surrender.


“Mulder!” Scully screamed, having wriggled her mouth free

of her captor’s hand. She’d seen Bruce Morgan move into

Mulder’s flashlight beam, and she’d heard him hit her

partner. Terror had gripped her as Mulder collapsed — and

as she’d heard his body being savaged with kicks. His

flashlight was now picked up by Morgan who shone it at her

partner as he stepped over the prone body.

“Bruce? What do I do now?”

The voice behind Scully’s ear was eloquent, resonant, each

word enunciated clearly. The arm that clutched her did so

without hurting her, and she felt herself being led

backward. She was forced to sit in a chair, but the hands

that had captured her remained on her shoulders, applying a

pressure that could easily turn violent.

“We need the lights back on, Bruce. Please? We have them

both now. We don’t have to hide.”

Scully heard Bruce Morgan plod forward, and a ceiling

light above her head suddenly radiated light. She squinted

against it until she could look at the kitchen surrounding

her. It was done mostly in white, a few blue items used as

trim. She sat in a wooden chair beside a tiny table, and

there were no windows.

“Agent Scully, we need to get out of here,” Bruce said as

he came into her vision. Mulder’s gun was in his waistband.

With shaking hands, he tied her wrists before her with an

electric cord. “You understand, don’t you? We don’t want to

hurt you.”

“Are you going to tie him, too?” Charlie asked.

Morgan looked back toward the darkened room. “He’s out.

We’ll be gone before he wakes — if he wakes.”

Scully felt Charlie’s hands leave her shoulders and

lightly rest on her head. Slowly, he began to feel and then

caress her hair. Shivers went down her spine as the

stroking increased in intensity. “What are you doing?” she

asked, trying to wrest away from the insistent pawing. To

further her attempt, she turned up toward her captor.

Charlie Morgan was tall and bony. His face was handsome

but wrinkled; his hair, quite gray. At the moment, his

expression showed rapture toward the copper locks between

his fingers.

Scully’s revulsion to his touch soared. To react too

harshly, though, could upset him, and she was in no

position to do that. Still, she tugged away from his hands.

But he was quick. He seized her head, pulling it back

against him, one hand firm beneath her chin, the other

continuing its petting.

“Silky. Smooth,” he cooed. “Soft. So soft.”

“No, not now. C’mon, Charlie. We have to get moving,”

Bruce instructed, his expression one of sorrow and anger.

“No, George. Silky. Soft. Pretty.”

“I’m not George. You’re not Lenny. Do you follow me,

little brother? You are *not* Lenny.”

“Like a rabbit,” Charlie was saying. “Soft like a bunny.”

His hand now stroked Scully’s hair so intensely that her

head was snapping back hard enough to hurt her neck.

“C’mon, we’ve got to get out of here. The cops…”

“Pretty. Like a rabbit.”

Scully felt the cord cutting into her wrists, felt her

neck becoming more taut each time Charlie stroked her hair.

She knew he could break her neck, and she knew that moment

could come shortly. She worried about Mulder’s injury, and

she refused to be hurt by or fall captive to the two men

planning their escape.

She watched as Bruce Morgan came closer, as he implored

his brother to return to reality. The elder Morgan now

stood within her reach, and she lashed out with her right

foot, connecting a powerful kick to his groin. His face

went white; his eyes bulged. And he crumbled to the floor,

groaning in pain.

Scully sprang to her feet. Then she reeled, looking for

Charlie. He stood behind the chair, shocked. She took

advantage of his hesitation, quickly scanning the floor for

her partner’s gun which Bruce had dropped. It lay a few

feet from her, and she started for it. But hands grasped

her ankles, and she fell forward, barely able to break her


She kicked, knowing that Bruce had recovered enough to

bring her down. He was pulling her backward, but she fought

to crawl toward the gun. Before she could reach it, though,

she felt Morgan’s weight pinning her to the linoleum floor

and forcing her to take shallow breaths.

“Get the gun, Charlie! Get it!”

Charlie did as told, lifting the weapon as if it were a

delicate artifact.

And Bruce roughly hauled Scully to her feet and held her.

He also gasped for air, and his posture was bent as he

favored his own injury. “You take her, Charlie,” he

instructed. “I’m going to get the van. Meet me outside.” He

shoved Scully into the hands of his confused brother.

“Shoot her if you have to.” He hobbled off to a door, left

it open, and limped up cement steps.

“You have to let me go, Charlie,” Scully gasped, searching

his vacant gaze. “You don’t want to hurt me, do you?”

“No, he doesn’t. And he won’t.”

Mulder appeared from the darkened living room. And as

Scully calmed, she could see that his eyes weren’t focused

and that being upright was costing him dearly. Lines of

pain streaked his face, and, unable to stand straight, he

held his elbows tightly against his rib cage. But even in

this state, he was thinking. His right hand held her

weapon. She was glad Bruce had overlooked it.

“Avaunt, and quit my sight!” Charlie suddenly shrieked,

pushing Scully away with such force that she fell to the

floor. “Let the earth hide thee!”

“That’s from ‘Macbeth,’ isn’t it? What the Scot says to

Banquo’s ghost.” Mulder’s voice was weak but calm; his

words, slurred. “You did that play in Poughkeepsie. But I’m

no ghost, Charlie.” And he added just loudly enough for

Scully to hear, “Though right now, being dead might feel


“I was an exquisite Macbeth,” Charlie replied.

“I believe that. You were a fine actor,” Mulder agreed. “I

read the reviews.”

“You did?” Charlie stared at Mulder as if seeing a long-

lost friend.

“Yeah. Too bad you had to quit.”

“I didn’t quit.” The younger Morgan suddenly sneered. “I

am the ghost of the Shady Rest.”

“And a murderer.”

Scully noticed that Mulder was taking small steps toward

them. Charlie, however, was caught up in his own mental

gymnastics and unaware of the agent’s movements.

“Yes, a murderer,” Charlie replied. “And a poor player

that struts and frets his hour upon the stage and then is

heard no more. Life, sir, is a tale told by an idiot, full

of sound and fury, signifying nothing.”

“More ‘Macbeth,'” Mulder observed. “But the play’s over

now, Charlie. Take a bow and ring the curtain down. Your

role here is done.”

Scully sat up, planning how best to help her partner.

“He’s right, Charlie.” She noticed that the gun remained

tight in the actor’s grip, his forefinger idly smoothing

over the trigger. She struggled, trying to get the electric

cord off her wrists. “Let’s call it a night.”

“Bruce… Bruce is waiting for me. We’ve got to go. I

don’t know where he’s taking me this time.” His voice had

become like a child’s.

“Would you rather come with us?” Mulder asked. “We can put

you on the stage. We can help you.”

“You can? Help me?”

Mulder nodded. “Put the gun down first, and then have a

seat. We’ll talk.”

“I… I don’t know. Bruce. He takes care of me.”

“Bruce can come, too. Put the gun down.”

“Charlie? Come on!” Bruce Morgan’s voice suddenly echoed

down the cellar stairway. “Bring the woman! Let’s go!”

“Woman…soft. Silky.” Charlie looked at Scully lovingly,

then glanced at Mulder. “I’m supposed to break her neck,

right? And then you shoot me in the head, George.”

“You’re not in ‘Of Mice and Men’ — not on 57th Street

now,” Mulder reminded him quietly. “This is Agent Scully of

the FBI. I’m Agent Mulder. We’re here to help you.”

“Silky, soft…did I hurt you?” He turned back to Scully.

“I’m fine. Put the gun down, okay?”

“Charlie? Where are you?” Bruce’s footsteps descended on

the cement.

“C’mon, Charlie, now. Put it down.” Mulder raised the

weapon in his hand, breathing hard when the movement

increased the pain in his side. “Let’s surprise your


“I don’t want to go with you. I want to go with Bruce.”

“What the…” The elder Morgan appeared in the doorway.

His face fell as he saw a gun pointed at his brother.

“It’s over, Mr. Morgan,” Scully said, getting to her feet.

“Tell your brother to put the weapon down. We don’t want

anyone else to get hurt.”

“You want me to shoot ’em?” Charlie asked, his eyes

narrowing. He raised the gun toward Scully.

“I’ll drop him in a second,” Mulder warned Bruce, his eyes

not leaving the younger Morgan. “You don’t want me to do

that, do you?”

Bruce Morgan’s gaze darted from one to the other of those

who stood before him. No words came as his mouth made

several attempts at protest. Finally, his shoulders drooped

as reality dawned. Tearfully, reluctantly, he stepped

toward his brother. “Do as they ask, Charlie.”

The younger man turned his head in shock. “We’re going

with them?”

“We have no choice.”

Charlie slowly backed away from the table. He moved toward

his brother, extending his arm as if to surrender the gun.

“We always have a choice.”

Just as Bruce was about to take the weapon, Charlie darted

for the steps. “I ‘gin to be aweary of the sun,” he said,

the voice he’d used earlier as Macbeth resounding in the

cellar. He then bolted up the stairs before anyone could


“NO!!” Bruce screamed, starting after him.

With a final twist, Scully’s wrists came free from the

cord. Mulder, his strength rapidly leaving him, took a few

wobbly steps but fell forward onto the table. The pain in

his head and ribs soared, but he managed to wave Scully on.

She grabbed her gun from him and had made it to the cellar

doorway — when they heard a shot. Then something dropped

to the floor overhead. Her mouth open in horror, Scully

looked back at Mulder who laboriously hauled himself to his

feet. Bruce Morgan had run upstairs, and they now heard him

howl morosely.

“Scully, my gun,” Mulder rasped. “Don’t let Bruce use it

on himself.”

She flew upstairs and into the Shady Rest’s lobby. In

front of the big oak counter, Bruce Morgan hunched over the

crumpled body of his brother, wailing. Cautiously, she

moved toward the duo, sliding past the elder and retrieving

the gun Charlie had turned on himself.

She knelt by Charlie but felt no carotid pulse, and as she

rolled him over, she found that he’d shot himself through

the heart. No CPR could save him.

“Bruce? Oh my God, Bruce?” Sheila Morgan’s voice came from

outside the locked front door. Her hands pounded rapidly on

its wood.

Scully rose and let Sheila in, saying, “Charlie’s dead.

And you’re both under arrest.”

“I know.” Sheila ran to her husband, pulling the tall

man’s head to her shoulder as he sobbed.

Scully heard a noise and turned to find that Mulder had

reached the top of the stairs. He slowly hobbled toward

her, becoming more pale.

She moved to support him, slinging his arm around her

shoulders. She gingerly touched his side and led him to the

maroon couch.

He melded into the cushions, lethargically moving his arms

from his side so she could do a cursory examination.

“Cracked ribs and a concussion, I’ll bet,” she said as his

eyes failed to follow the forefinger she moved laterally to

test his focus.

“So much for rest and relaxation, huh, Scully?”

“Anyone ever tell you you have lousy taste in vacations,


“No, but I’m sure you will.”



9:25 p.m., August 26, Belcan

“I’m sorry that you have to leave so soon,” Clarissa

McKinnie said, leaning toward the passenger side of the

Intrigue. “Are you sure you’ll be able to travel?”

Mulder nodded drowsily. “I’m looking forward to getting


“I can’t believe the hospital released you this evening.

You should have spent the night there.”

“He can’t wait to get back to D.C.,” Scully observed from

the driver’s seat. “Desk duty is one of his favorite jobs.”

Mulder winced at her words. “Clarissa, it was nice to meet


“Likewise,” she replied. She kissed him lightly on the

cheek. “And I want you to have this.” She held out a post

card. “I got a few extra a while back, and since the place

is now closed down, you should have the last souvenir.”

Mulder squinted, reading the card in the car’s dome light.

“‘I survived the Shady Rest’.”

“That’s perfect,” Scully smiled as she checked her watch.

“We’ve got to get going. Plane to catch.”

“Gotta get back to her assistant director, eh?” Clarissa

whispered to Mulder. “Come see us again sometime. And I’ll

talk to you on the Net.” She waved at them, and turned

toward her apartment.

As Scully started the car, Mulder looked across the road

at the Shady Rest, now completely shrouded in darkness. “A

shame, Scully. It really wasn’t a bad place.”

She followed his gaze. “No, not with the right people.

Sorry there was no ghost.”

“I knew there wasn’t. But finding Charlie Morgan after all

these years was too intriguing.” As his partner shifted the

car into drive and left the curb, he muttered, “Bye,

Belcan. Parting is such sweet sorrow.”

“I’ve had enough Shakespeare,” Scully groaned. “But tell

me, why’d Charlie kill himself?”

Mulder unfolded their map and shone his flashlight on it.

“Maybe reality finally set in. He didn’t want to face

prison or an institution. Or maybe he just couldn’t face

giving up his acting. Maybe suicide was his final lucid


Scully silently considered this. “Too bad his mental

illness wasn’t given due awareness. If Bruce had just…oh

well. Too late now.”


She looked over at him. “You have the map? How far till we

hit Buffalo?”

“About three inches.”

They drove off, then, into the darkness. Behind them,

though, the lights on the Shady Rest’s second floor

suddenly blinked. Twice. And on the second time, a white

figure seemed to appear in the window of Room 25.


AUTHOR’S NOTES: Thanks to William Shakespeare, Susan

Glaspell, Edgar Allen Poe, and John Steinbeck for

unknowingly lending me their titles, characters, or words.

Heartfelt thanks to the wonderful Michelle,

FabulousMonster, Clarissa, Laura, Nicola, and Catbird for

invaluable friendship, beta work, and encouragement.

Special gratitude to Michelle Kiefer and FabulousMonster

for ideas that helped this story immensely. And thanks,

too, to Laine and all the Crystal Shippers for being such

good people. I really don’t deserve any of you!

Please visit my website:

Paper Visions

2 thoughts on “Shady Rest”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s